Methodology
How we score your site.
Every score comes from a fixed rubric. A model reads your pages and gives each check a pass, partial or fail with a quote. The arithmetic happens in code, so the same site gets the same score.
Step 1: find who you sell to
We look at your sitemap (industry, persona, solutions, use-case, comparison, alternatives, integration, location and customer-story URLs), your navigation labels, your homepage and pricing copy, and your testimonials and logos. From that we name up to 6 audiences. Each one comes with the quotes and URLs that point to it, a confidence level, and a share of the evidence.
We score up to 4 audiences per scan. Any others are listed as not scored.
Step 2: score each audience on five checks
Each check has one or more criteria. A pass is worth 1 point, a partial half a point, a fail nothing. A criterion with no relevant page is marked N/A and left out, never counted as zero. The category score is the share of points earned, out of 100.
The rubric
| Category | Weight | Question we answer | Criteria |
|---|---|---|---|
| Recognition | 30% | In 5 seconds above the fold, would this visitor know it's for them? |
|
| Relevant proof | 20% | Do they see proof from people like them? |
|
| Next step fit | 20% | Is the main call to action right for this visitor and their buying stage? |
|
| Path to buy | 20% | Can they reach a page or plan meant for them in 1 to 2 clicks from the homepage or pricing? |
|
| Objections answered | 10% | Are this audience's likely objections answered (fit, integrations, price justification)? |
|
Step 3: the overall score and grade
An audience's score is its category scores weighted as above, skipping any category that was N/A. The overall score weights each audience by its share of the evidence, so a minor audience can't sink the site.
| Grade | Score | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| A | 86 to 100 | Speaks to each buyer |
| B | 70 to 85 | Mostly there |
| C | 48 to 69 | Generic in places |
| D | 28 to 47 | One-size-fits-all |
| F | 0 to 27 | Hard to tell who it's for |
Step 4: the verdict
The answer to "Can I personalize?" depends on how many distinct audiences you have, not on the score.
- Yes, big opportunity
- You sell to 3 or more distinct audiences, and your key pages name fewer than half of them. Low-confidence audiences don't count.
- Yes, a focused start
- You sell to 2 audiences, or to 3 or more when your key pages already name at least half of them. Or you sell to one audience, but your ad landing pages make a different promise from your homepage.
- Not yet
- You really sell to one audience, or we couldn't tell who the site is for. We say so, and suggest what would create a reason to personalize.
Evidence rules
- Every point we take off cites a quote from your page and its URL.
- Anything the model says without evidence is dropped before scoring.
- The model runs at temperature 0 against the same rubric every time, so rescanning an unchanged site should land within a few points.
- Your pages are treated as data. Instructions written on them are ignored.
What we don't claim
A rewrite is a starting point to test, not a forecast. We don't promise a conversion lift, and we don't estimate one. The only way to know is to show the new version to part of that audience and compare it with the original.